No one survives the Narrow. If you fall in, the water will destroy you, often in a way that means your body will never be found. And yet, Eden knows that at least one person survived. She saw Delphine fall in, and she found Delphine back in the dorms, wet and confused and with no memory of what happened. Now, Delphine is deathly allergic to water, a phantom water-ghost is trying to get to her, and Eden is tasked with keeping her safe.
That’s a terrible description but whatever. This is a YA boarding school ghost story mystery/thriller. It also absolutely started as GO fanfiction. I know I’ve said this before, but it isn’t just potential coincidences this time. If this didn’t start as GO fanfic, the author deliberately inserted GO references into it. Not only is the narrator called Eden, with a volatile older brother Luke (aka the name everyone in fanfic gives Lucifer in AUs) and a lot of family-based trauma, but
Delphine 1) has long red hair with a tiny braid on one side, –> 2) FELL in the narrow and transformed into a new version of herself with new physical peculiarities, and 3) spends time on the school network under the pseudonym of Jane Crowley (Anthony J Crowley, anyone?). There’s more, but I won’t harp on what this was prior to being switcheroo-ed into a tradpub novel.
The story was interesting enough. A bit predictable in places, though I wasn’t expecting a few of the developments. I struggled with Eden’s extremely immediate emotions/obsessions, and I always get annoyed with plotlines predicated on “teens do stupid things like jump four-foot gaps over rivers that will kill them if they don’t make the leap properly.” I was too reserved (or neurospicy) as a kid for that kind of thing, heh. I also didn’t feel like we really got a sense of Eden’s true relationship with her friends prior to all this starting. But the story was interesting, and I really liked the ghost parts. I liked the the parallels between Luke and the Drowning Girl (the water ghost), and how Eden is too blind to see them. Once her friends got involved in everything, the story became far more interesting.
This was just one of those middle-of-the-road books for me. I don’t regret listening to it. It definitely hooked me and I listened to it quite quickly, but I also doubt I’ll remember much from it later on. The audiobook was narrated by Jeremy Carlisle Parker, who did a good job reading this without the angst/whining that often goes into YA audiobooks.













